What I Wish I Focused on While Leading an OSC Team

What I Wish I Focused on While Leading an OSC Team

Nov 17, 2026 | By Nicole Maggio-Deaton

Sometimes you don’t know what you don’t know. Sometimes you know, but maybe you just don’t do it, because your day is so crammed with meetings that all you want to do is shut your office door and hide from the world, just to have a chance to work on something you deem as productive! Cue the poorly timed ping of your inbox that sends you over the edge. But what parts of your role as an online sales leader truly matter and will help take your team from good to great?

When you are knee-deep in those moments, it takes someone who's lived the life you’re living to step back, get perspective, and share what they wish they had known then. And lucky for you, I was in that place until recently.

After a few months of diving head-first into the Online Sales Coach role, I had so many “aha” and “why didn’t I do this?!?” moments that have inspired me to think back on my former role of leading an OSC team and think of all the things I could’ve done better during that time. And since I don’t gatekeep good nuggets of information, here are the four key thoughts I have had from this new vantage point.

Don’t Let Your Team Avoid Metrics

If you haven’t read Melissa’s article from September on OSCs truly owning their metrics to better tell the story of their role, start there. 

That article might have been geared toward OSCs, but it is important to know that you, as a leader, still have a big (if not the biggest) part to play here. While outside knowledge from industry pros is a great place to start, accountability starts within your company, and most of the time, with you! Yes, some people are self-starters and can read something and immediately put it into practice. But even the self-starters look to their leaders for encouragement and accountability.

If you think just sending an email that says, “Look at your metrics, you fabulous OSC!” will make it happen, I am here to break the news that it most likely will not. Depending on the strengths of those on your teams, sometimes getting buy-in for the whole spreadsheet thing can prove to be pretty challenging. Let me clue you in on some of the things you will hear:
  • “I am not good at spreadsheets.”
  • “I am not a numbers person.”
  • “I am a salesperson; data is not for me.”
  • “I hate this spreadsheet!”
  • “Actually, this spreadsheet hates me!” *Bangs head on desk*
This is the important part: You cannot accept this! You won’t be doing your OSCs any favors by letting them off the hook here. One of my OSCs hated spreadsheets when she first started in the role. It was her nemesis month after month, and we had a lead OSC that was inputting most of the monthly numbers, so I accepted it and moved on. I let that go on for a while, not realizing how much I was stunting her growth. So, when our lead OSC went on maternity leave and left behind one spreadsheet hater to keep it rolling for a few months, you can imagine what that started out like. Spoiler alert: it wasn't fun for either of us, and it wasn't as accurate as it needed to be. But at that point, I didn’t absolve her of all spreadsheet duties just because it wasn’t a strength. We sat down side by side and went through the numbers to help her make more sense of them. It was a process, but gradually she got way more confident not only in using said spreadsheet, but also in finding her metrics to see how she was contributing to the company.

As a leader, it’s your job to push your team beyond their comfort zone and show that you believe they can grow past what they thought was possible. That means making sure they have full access to their metrics (remember, we don’t gatekeep!) and spending time reviewing those any time you are in front of them to help them build that muscle.

One-On-Ones Are a Must

While we are on the topic of meeting with your team, one-on-one meetings with each person should make it to your priority list when it comes to leading. And this can be said for any team you lead, not just online sales. During coaching calls, I hear firsthand how much OSCs appreciate the time they have with their leaders, whether it is role-playing objections or simply knowing they have someone who cares about what they do. While I had a pretty good track record for staying consistent with my one-on-ones, there were always a few months out of the year when things just got away from me, and we skipped them. Not good! The team looked forward to them, and I always felt like I let them down in those months. 

There are so many great reasons to get these on your calendar ASAP if they are not already. It gives you time to build a trusting, working relationship with everyone who reports to you. It also gives those who might not feel comfortable approaching you sporadically a planned time to bring their questions, concerns, and how they see themselves growing in the role. Last but certainly not least, it helps your team feel seen. It’s amazing how often I heard how much they appreciated the time we spent together and how much they looked forward to it.

Let’s address the elephant in the room before we go any further. A one-on-one is not the same as just having a conversation with your team throughout the week. Saying that you speak to your team isn’t a one-on-one. That is just basic communication! When I talk about a successful one-on-one, I mean a planned encounter with a set agenda. 

Many leaders dread a one-on-one meeting because it is one more meeting to prepare for. That can seem daunting when you look at your work calendar and barely see space to scarf down your lunch at your desk on certain days. I understand this in the depths of my SOUL. But the beauty of the one-on-one is that your team should carry most of the preparation weight. Hallelujah! So, let that “oh no, I have to have another meeting” tension drop from your shoulders, and lock in for the secrets to easy one-on-ones.
  • Step 1: Get a recurring meeting on the calendar. I can say from experience that this is the hardest part. I didn't have recurring meetings, but it is something I wish I had. This would’ve been one less thing to think about monthly. Another option is to have a scheduling link where your team can take ownership and schedule it with you monthly themselves.
  • Step 2: Have a consistent agenda. This should not change from month to month. Start with a win, review key metrics together, review the CRM, listen to a call, talk about what the OSCs are hearing, and don’t forget to check in on a personal level too.  
  • Step 3: Place the ownership of preparation on your team. This should be their meeting, not yours, so let them own it by doing the planning. By offering a consistent agenda, as mentioned in the prior step, you hold them accountable for coming prepared.

It can really be that simple! I have never left a one-on-one meeting regretting having it. Even the tough ones where things got deep. In fact, I added more of them to my plate for our marketing team, who weren’t having them before, because I saw their value. You will gain important information about your team while also showing your intention to help them grow in the best way they can in their careers. A true win-win!

Don’t Let Online Sales Be Forgotten

I have found that when a team has the gist of what they are doing, it is extremely easy to push your online sales team to the back burner. And it is never intentional. Many builders don’t have a large enough online sales team to require separate leadership; often, the online sales team is merged with the sales or marketing teams and falls under their leadership, as it did in my case. When you are in the throes of directly managing a marketing team with things that are ever-changing, online sales can seem like the North Star, something stable you can look towards and take a sigh of relief that it is consistent. What I learned is that I created a self-soothing false narrative to help me feel okay when I didn’t give this role the attention it deserved.

All teams, no matter how consistent their role can seem, need your attention, and online sales is no different. After all, they start the in-person customer journey and provide the first look at the brand and the experience prospective buyers will continue to see throughout their process. They have the word on the street of what those they talk to are saying, and that feedback can be priceless to both you and other departments.

Another thing that can happen when you keep kicking the can of online sales leadership down the road is that they can become complacent. They might not push themselves to reach the next levels you know they are capable of because no one is paying attention and they feel they are flying under the radar. Once again, one-on-ones are a great way to ensure you meet with them at least once a month for coaching and guidance (are you seeing the pattern here about the importance of the one-on-one?) But that is the bare minimum.

I found myself relying solely on one-on-one meetings for a while to convey everything I needed to my team, but I realized that wasn't enough. Having time to positively reinforce helpful habits throughout the month would have helped us gain momentum and move the needle further. So, remember to set aside time each week to approach your OSCs and create a more proactive versus reactive environment. 

You Didn’t Have to Have Been an OSC to Lead – But You Do Need to Understand the Role

Many leaders find themselves managing teams in a role that they never held, including myself in my past life. Talk about imposter syndrome! Now, I did have on-site sales experience under my belt, and a lot can cross over between the two. I also appreciated our OSCs and understood their contribution when I was selling on-site. But as I quickly found out, a lot of that did not translate directly from one role to the other.

When I stepped in and started leading, I took the time to meet with the team and sit alongside them so I could better understand their day-to-day, but as I grew as a leader, my time for that began to dwindle. I also realized I didn’t need to dive into the nitty-gritty details of each role I was managing; I just needed to understand how to lead them best and trust that they knew their day-to-day.   

Fast forward to when I stepped into the Online Sales Coach role and had the opportunity to go through the Online Sales Academy. I had so many moments of realization as I made progress and quickly understood how learning more of the intricacies of the role would’ve helped me so much. Understanding follow-up processes for ratings and long-term prospecting at a deeper level would’ve helped me guide the team more effectively.

I’m not saying you need to stop everything now and go through the full-blown OSC training process to be successful in this role. Instead, do a quick self-assessment of where you are currently in terms of understanding the Online Sales role. From there, how can you add even one extra layer of knowledge? It can be as simple as stopping to ask in more detail about how something is done each time you meet with your team. That extra layer of knowledge gives you the opportunity to take your team to the next level by understanding and speaking their language. 

Perspective is a funny thing. It doesn’t do much for you the moment you are earning it, but down the road, it allows you to help those around you in a big way. Being able to look back is great, but not everyone has that luxury, as they are knee-deep in the role. I hope that if you can pull anything from this, it is to continue having a growth mindset through the ups and downs of the market and the days jam-packed with meetings. Take small steps toward metrics, meet consistently with your OSCs, and understand what they are doing day in and day out. Most of all, don’t be afraid to lean on those around you who have earned that perspective as you lead your fearless OSC teams into the future! 

Online Sales & Marketing Insights Delivered Straight To Your Inbox

Get Free Insights